Transitions
The First Big Goodbye
On starting babies in care slowly, and trying to do it well with my own.
I’ve been thinking a lot about how we start babies in care, partly because I’m in the middle of it with my own.
By the time a baby begins care, they’ve spent their whole life learning one small world. Their house, their people, how they get picked up, how naps go. Then one day almost all of it changes at once. If I started a new job and moved to a new house in the same week, I’d be a wreck, and I’d at least understand what was happening.
I’ve seen this over and over as a nanny, and the research matches. In one study, toddlers starting childcare around 15 months had cortisol (a stress hormone) 75 to 100 percent above their home levels within an hour of mom leaving, for the first couple of weeks. While moms were still in the room, the securely attached kids’ levels stayed lower. Once the goodbyes started, everyone’s went up. The securely attached kids also cried more, and their crying matched what was going on inside. By five months, levels had come down a lot, and the researchers said there’s no evidence yet that this kind of mild stress does harm.
What stuck with me was time. The more days moms spent at the center with their kids, the more likely those kids were to stay securely attached, or become secure. Moms chose how long to stay, though, so it’s a pattern, not a rule. And just as many kids were securely attached after starting care as before. Another study found the first days without a parent were the most stressful, and that younger toddlers might need a little longer.
I’m not saying care is bad. I clearly don’t think that. I just think the first few weeks deserve more thought than they usually get. NAEYC suggests visiting first, starting with short days, and always saying goodbye, even when it’s tempting to sneak out. Slipping away just makes a kid more worried about whether you’re coming back.
There’s usually crying. Honestly, I think that’s fine. When a baby protests a goodbye, it shows how much their parent matters to them. We don’t have to fix that. We stay close, say what’s happening, and let them figure out over a lot of goodbyes and a lot of pickups that someone new can be safe too.
My daughter Zosia is 16 months, and this is her transition too. Gillian has been babysitting her since she was about 7 months old, so she’s starting with someone she already knows and loves. Right now they have one full day together each week. Over the next several weeks we’re going to two days, then three, and after our inspection there will be more babies in the house too.
Eighteen years as a nanny taught me how much a predictable goodbye matters, and I’ll be honest, I still don’t always follow my own advice. Our goodbyes don’t always look the same, and some days I’m working where she can see me and some days I’m not. I can tell that’s a little hard for her. So that’s what I’m working on: saying goodbye every time, even if I’m just going upstairs, and keeping the rest of it as steady as I can.
I’m sure it won’t go perfectly. I also know that going at her pace is a privilege. A lot of parents don’t get to choose a slow start. Leave ends and work starts, and that’s that. If that’s you, it doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong. The small things still count: the same goodbye every time, a familiar blanket, telling them when you’ll be back and then coming back.
